In today’s newscast, we explore the possible outcomes of Deere’s lawsuits against Precision Planting and AGCO, how high-speed ISOBUS will expedite plug & play compatibility, Titan Machinery’s first quarter earnings for fiscal year 2019, an improvement in farmer and rancher sentiment and changes to the Financial Accounting Standards Board’s accounting standards for companies that lease equipment.

On the Record is brought to you by Spader Business Management.

Spader Business Management’s team of industry experts provide business insights, ideas and concrete tactics through training and consulting. Generations of business owners and operators have also relied on our 20 Groups to capitalize on new opportunities and industry trends by learning directly from their peers. Learn more at spader.com.

SpaderLogoTagNew-Large.png

On the Record is now available as a podcast! We encourage you to subscribe in iTunes, the Google Play Store, Soundcloud, Stitcher Radio and TuneIn Radio. Or if you have another app you use for listening to podcasts, let us know and we’ll make an effort to get it listed there as well.

We’re interested in getting your feedback. Please feel free to send along any suggestions or story ideas. You can send comments to kschmidt@lessitermedia.com.


I’m managing editor Kim Schmidt. Welcome to On the Record! Here’s an update on what’s currently impacting the ag equipment industry.

Deere Sues Precision Planting, AGCO

Deere & Co. filed a lawsuit June 1 against Precision Planting and AGCO claiming the companies infringed on about a dozen John Deere patents related to the ExactEmerge planter.

Deere filed separate complaints against Precision Planting and AGCO, claiming that when you combine the SpeedTube and vSet Classic or vSet 2 seed metering systems that it infringes on the ExactEmerge system, explains ag attorney Todd Janzen.

In the lawsuit, Deere claims it “has suffered damages as a result of the direct and indirect infringing activities of [the] Defendant and will continue to suffer such damages as long as those infringing activities continue.”

If the court rules in favor of Deere, Janzen says there are a few potential outcomes.

“In patent infringement litigation, one thing the court could do is reward royalties to Deere for profits made by SpeedTube and vSet and how that may have caused Deere damages. That’s one thing they could do. If they [AGCO/Precision Planting] continue to keep selling them going forward, the court could set a royalty that Precision Planting would have to pay Deere for sales going forward. Or, another thing that could happen is if it’s determine that the patents are infringed, then the court could enjoin Precision Planting and AGCO from selling the SpeedTube and vSet combination in the future until the patent expires.”

While AGCO has not commented on the lawsuit, Janzen says it is possible AGCO could file a counterclaim saying ExactEmerge infringes on some of their patents. However, he stresses that is just speculation at this point.

He also says it could be years before the case is settled.

Dealers on the Move

This week’s Dealers on the Move are Koenig Equipment, KanEquip, Hyde Park Equipment and Wagner Equipment.

John Deere dealer Koenig Equipment is acquiring the assets and operations of Cahall Brothers in Amelia, Ohio. The addition brings Koenig's total locations to 15 throughout Ohio and Indiana.

KanEquip has reached an agreement with McConnell Machinery Co. to acquire its Ottawa, Kan., location and Case IH territory. McConnell will keep its Lawrence store location and Kubota territory. The acquisition brings KanEquip’s total locations up to 9 in Kansas and Nebraska.

Kubota dealer Hyde Park Equipment opened a new location in London, Ont., that offers a much larger shop than the old location, in addition to offices and a showroom.

AGCO dealer Wagner Equipment, has acquired the business assets of H. Manning Co. in Lamar, Colo. Wagner now has 11 ag equipment locations.

Now here’s James DeGraff with the latest from the Technology Corner.

High-Speed ISOBUS to Expedite “Plug-&-Play” Compatibility

Last month, I traveled to Lincoln, Neb., to cover the Agricultural Electronics Foundation Plugfest event. For hours on end, developers from around the world tested their platforms for compatibility in a round-robin format, hoping to fix any underlying issues en route to eventually achieving ISOBUS certification.

Among the many compatibility veterans in attendance was Dave Smart, staff systems engineer with John Deere and head of AEF’s high-speed ISOBUS development project. In working with AEF since 2001, Smart has contributed to the research and development of ag compatibility, helping develop universal standards to connect machines, implements and data for growers.

Speaking on behalf of his work with AEF and the industry wide goal of universal “plug-&-play” compatibility across all brands, Smart explains the current limitations of CAN-based ISOBUS in the field, and how the eventual implementation of an enhanced, high-speed ISOBUS network will provide unprecedented bandwidth for data collection and brand-to-brand functionality.

“The speed of CAN is very slow, and it's not unlike the dial-up modem from many years ago in the terms of performance. (It’s) no longer adequate in anybody’s home in these modern times, I would say. So the high-speed ISOBUS is intended to give us that next capability from an infrastructure perspective, and even though many of the operations would still be the same sort of thing, we still have the user experience, we still have prescription being applied, data logging and so forth. But now, instead of saying the planter's delivering 32,000 seeds per acre as the set point, and it’s actually 31.5, we could instead have the bandwidth to get down to row level, and what is each row doing? And do I actually have a need to have a prescription that can adjust row-by-row-by-row?”

While acknowledging that the network is still under development, Smart adds that growers will have the ability for camera integration on implements for access to real-time viewing and data collection from the cab. Should it all come together as expected, perhaps we’re a lot closer to true “plug-&-play” than many would be led to believe.

Titan Machinery 1Q19 Revenues Down 6.9%

Titan Machinery reported its first quarter revenues for fiscal year 2019 on May 31. For the quarter ending April 30, total revenues were $245.7 million, down 6.9% vs. the same period last year.

Agriculture segment revenues were down 12.7% for the quarter at $142.9 million. A late spring delayed field preparation and planting, negatively impacting revenue, particularly in the parts and service and rental segments, management said.

Titan-Machinery-1Q-FY2019.jpg

Baird analyst Mig Dobre says, while weather played a role in the slower than anticipated start, management also acknowledge some farmer hesitancy as ever-shifting stances on “trade wars” created a sense of uncertainty.

Dobre says, “Revenue was weak but execution on cost has improved and most importantly, Parts and Service remains a key earnings driver the impact of which is yet to be felt. Weather played a big role here, with both Parts and Service down 9% and 5%, respectively.”

Dobre also points out that this business has now declined for 4 straight years while the fleet has gotten older. He also notes that as planting activity picked up in the second quarter, parts and service demand is up year-over-year with momentum expected to continue as the year progresses.

Ag Producers Optimism Increases

The May Purdue University/Center for Commercial Agriculture Ag Economy Barometer posted the highest reading since January 2017. The May reading was 141, which is 16 points higher than the April reading. James Mintert and Michael Langemeier who assembled the report say the increase was driven both by producers improved view of current conditions and their more optimistic view of the future.

Ag-Economy-Barometer.jpg

Looking ahead 12 months, 32% of producers expect good times in U.S. agriculture, up from 25% a month earlier. When asked to look ahead 5 years, 51% of respondents said they expect good times in U.S. agriculture compared to 44% who felt that way in April.

Ag-Economy-Barometer_better-worse.jpg

According to Mintert and Langemeier, the improvement in sentiment regarding the U.S. ag economy could be a function of a relaxation in international trade tensions with China compared to a month earlier when nearly one-fifth of respondents expressed concern that U.S. agricultural exports will decline over the next 5 years.

Ag-Economy-May-Barometer-Good-times-for-large-investments.jpg

While over all producer sentiment has improved, the survey indicated the majority of farmers don’t plan to make large farm investments at this time. The May survey showed only 27% of producers said now is a good time to make large farm investments compared to 28% who felt that way in April and 67% of respondents said now is a bad time to make large investments compared to 69% who responded that way one month earlier.

New Lease Accounting Standards

Farm Equipment dealers who lease equipment will soon have to adjust their accounting practices thanks to a new standard that goes into effect next year.

The new accounting standard for leases require both operating and finance leases be included on a company’s balance sheet. The new standard goes into effect on January 1 for companies whose fiscal years end on December 31.

Ralph Petta, president and CEO of Equipment Leasing and Finance Assn., noted last year in Farm Equipment that the new lease accounting changes are “relatively neutral and should not impact the ability of companies to acquire productive equipment to operate and grow their businesses.”

One of the key changes is that leases previously classified as operating leases under current accounting standards will now be capitalized and thus reported on corporate balance sheets. With the changes in balance sheet reporting, some financial statement ratios may be affected. 
Under the new standards, operating leases will no longer appear simply as a table of future payments in the footnotes; they will appear as a “right-of-use” asset and an offsetting lease liability on the balance sheet.

A guide to implementing these new accounting practices can be found on the Pine Hill Group website.

Pine-Hill-Group.jpg

And now from the Implement & Tractor Archive…

Implement & Tractor Archives

Implement-and-Tractor-Archives3.jpg

In the 1960s Case built a special prototype tractor that was used to illustrate tractor repair in the Dealer Service Manual. The manual was available when the tractor was introduced to the dealers. Many of the special tools dealers would need to service the product, such as the splitting stands pictured, were developed in the Case Technical Publications photo studio and shop while the Service Manual was being completed. Writers and mechanics worked together to develop the procedures and techniques needed to service a tractor. The procedures were then photographed step-by-step and included in the Service Manual. This eliminated any possible translation errors with language.

As always, we welcome your feedback. You can send comments and story suggestions to kschmidt@lessitermedia.com. Until next time, thanks for joining us.