I was curious to see what the price increase has been for combines over the past 3 model changes. I looked through the business system, locating customers who have rolled combines every year, trying to see how pricing has evolved over the last decade. What I found was not all that shocking, but at the same time I have to wonder how long trading the volume of equipment with high used pricing can be sustained. This is not to say a 2018 combine and 2008 combine are the same. The amount of technology and overall improvements in the past 10 years are tremendously vast. So, this goes without saying, R&D cost will be recaptured but with this comes a challenge of its own. When a manufacturer has a price increase, it does affect the used market but not the entire price increase. In the the last 5 years, the rate of price increase recapture has been less than the previous 5 years.
The Ask the Expert: Used Equipment series allows dealers to regularly ask questions and get them answered in real time. It is brought to you courtesy of Iron Solutions.
At Iron Solutions, we provide used equipment valuations, market intelligence and a suite of integrated, cloud-based business systems custom-tailored for the equipment industry. Our proprietary model is built on actual dealer sales transaction data. Learn more…
As mentioned earlier, I went and found customers who have traded combines every year since 2008. For the most part, the combines they order are the same year-after-year. The codes all lined up except for when a model change happened and an option that was extra became standard, like a particular transmission or a new option not available on the previous series. The particular customer I picked bought the 2008 combine, in round numbers, for $240,000. Fast forward 10 years and the current model, all major options staying the same, sold for $383,000. For example, 2WD v. 4WD, chopper v. spreader, so on and so forth. The basics are all the same.
The market in 2008 was different than 2018. On-farm income was on the rise and dealerships where having some of the best years ever. This also marked the beginning of the used combine pile up on dealer lots. Over the next 5 years, used combines became the mainstay at any auction — live or on the internet. This had nothing to due with lack of on farm income. It had everything to do with above average on-farm income.
Fast forward to 2018, dealer groups are selling used combines for the same amount as they were new in 2008, which is true of any era. The lack of buyers we have is directly tied to lower on-farm income; no big surprise here. So, what happens when the market turns around? The producer looking for a new machine who is truly a new machine buyer will always buy new. What I have concerns about is whether or not the difference between the 1-2 year old machine will be great enough that the secondary buyer will be incentivized to buy used machines.
Currently on any internet listing site, used combines can be found for $350,000 and higher. In the current market the producer who can afford a $350,000 or higher combine is also the same producer who is buying new. So, this leaves me to question where is the balance between new trade difference and used pricing for the secondary market met?
Unfortunately, I don’t have the answers to this problem. Used combine internet listings are slowly creeping up every month. There’s a completely different set of obstacles dealers are being faced with today than in 2008, including trade issues, lower on-farm-income, raising interest rates and fewer used buyers than 10 years ago. These obstacles aren’t bigger; just different. More producers are buying equipment because they have to instead of because they want to. Late model and low hour equipment isn’t readily available. There is demand for this equipment, but the price will continue to play a roll. Payment structures will have to continue to be creative and a few interest rate percentage points will be the difference in a producer buying a piece of equipment or not. This is a market ripe for the picking. It will just take a different tool than the past.